skip navigation
The Read Menace - Commentary by Tom Bartel
Sarah Palin, Sock Puppet. Coincidence that they have the same initials?

Sarah Palin, Sock Puppet. Coincidence that they have the same initials?

Submitted by Tom Bartel on Friday, September 12, 2008

The McCain campaign has taken Obama to task for supposedly saying Sarah Palin will do what she's told. I can't say whether anyone really said that Palin will do what she's told, but the evidence of her appearance with Charlie Gibson on ABC certainly suggests she SAYS what she's told.

When Gibson asked her if she would back Israel if Israel were to attack Iran's nuclear facilities she said, "I don’t think that we should second-guess the measures that Israel has to take to defend themselves."

In fact, she's so anxious to not "second guess" Israel -- or her handlers' talking points -- she repeated it three times. Here's how it went:

GIBSON: What if Israel decided it felt threatened and needed to take out the Iranian nuclear facilities?

PALIN: Well, first, we are friends with Israel and I don't think that we should second guess the measures that Israel has to take to defend themselves and for their security.

GIBSON: So if we wouldn't second guess it and they decided they needed to do it because Iran was an existential threat, we would cooperate or agree with that.

PALIN: I don't think we can second guess what Israel has to do to secure its nation.

GIBSON: So if it felt necessary, if it felt the need to defend itself by taking out Iranian nuclear facilities, that would be all right.

PALIN: We cannot second guess the steps that Israel has to take to defend itself.

Continued advertisement

What was amazing to me is that she repeated the lines so effortlessly, and I couldn't even detect Karl Rove's hand up her back.

So, now we know we have a person who can memorize things, and who believes what she's told, (as if her creationist pronouncements weren't evidence enough of that). We also know that McCain has picked a "running mate" as opposed to a Vice President. Do you want Palin up against Vladimir Putin, when her understanding of Russia is this?

GIBSON: What insight into Russian actions, particularly in the last couple of weeks, does the proximity of the state give you?

PALIN: They're our next door neighbors and you can actually see Russia from land here in Alaska, from an island in Alaska.

One thing is sure. Rove didn't give her that line. She thought that up all by herself, which is even more terrifying.

The Wisdom of the Car Buying Masses

The Wisdom of the Car Buying Masses

Submitted by Tom Bartel on Thursday, May 1, 2008

Just when I thought it was safe to cancel my Strib subscription, they surprise me and put something on the front page that actually 1) contains information that I care about; 2) contains information that elucidates a larger story; and 3) nudges at least one piece of television-like spot news dreck out of the paper. (Actually, I’m only guessing about point number 3.)

Today, there was a good piece by Dee DePass about the slump in car buying in the Twin Cities. It seems new car and truck buying was down 14.5 percent last year. Used car sales were also down—by 12 percent.

Of course, these were sales by dealers, and if there’s one thing we should have learned over the past few years is that we don’t need dealers anymore of almost any type. We have the internet, and sites like Carsoup and Craig’s List, make it a lot easier to sell your car yourself and cut out the dealer’s commission.

So, perhaps the numbers are a little skewed, but a table accompanying the story gives some detail that is relevant. (Sorry if you read the story online. The table wasn’t attached to the online version of the story. Is there a worse web site in the world than the Strib’s?)

The table showed basically that the sales of American brands are down, for the most part, 15 to 20 percent. On the other hand, Toyotas, Hondas, Volkswagens, and other efficient foreign models were up. Not down less than Americans. Their sales were actually higher.

Continued advertisement

Is there anything to be inferred from this? I’m going to go out on a limb and say Americans have wised up way faster than their automobile company executives and noticed that gas prices are rising and are making adjustments such as buying smaller more efficient cars.

This is a roundabout way of getting to presidential politics. Recently, both Hillary Clinton and John McCain have called for a temporary reduction of the gas tax. Because of course, we want to do everything we can to encourage Americans to drive more, take no responsibility either on the personal or political front for the idiocy of our national energy policy, and just keep paying out to our pals in Saudi Arabia and Venezuela.

This at the same time as they laughingly call for a reduction of greenhouse gas emissions. It just gets funnier.

No Surprise Here, UnitedHealth Rides Again

No Surprise Here, UnitedHealth Rides Again

Submitted by Tom Bartel on Wednesday, February 20, 2008

It's not any surprise to those who've followed the sordid history of UnitedHealth Group to see that the company is being sued by the Attorney General of New York for manipulating the reimbursement rates for their insured who go outside of the network for their care.

It seems United reimburses its customers based on a formula which calculates the "customary" charges for services in the New York area. Of course, the "customary" charges are calculated by a third party. In this case a company called Ingenix, which happens to be owned by UnitedHealth.

An investigation by the state showed that a "customary" charge for a doctor visit in New York City was $200. Ingenix said it was $77. I don't know if any of you have been to the doctor lately, but the charge in Minneapolis passed $77 quite some time ago. I'm fairly certain that I read somewhere that New York is more expensive to live in than Minneapolis.

As NY Attorney General Andrew Cuomo said, “We believe there was an industrywide scheme perpetuated by some of the nation’s largest health insurers to deceive and defraud consumers.”

Ya think?

 

advertisement
...leaving community hurt, too

...leaving community hurt, too

Submitted by Tom Bartel on Friday, February 15, 2008

Here's the headline from yesterday's Strib: "Girl, 6, is grazed by bullet, leaving community hurt, too."

It's tempting just to let that stand as one more blob in the insipid lump of goo that is the Star Tribune. OK, I will, but with just one comment: Doesn't every bullet that hits a six-year-old hurt our community?

I wish I had such an overstaffed news room that I could send a reporter out to the scene of a shooting to ask everyone who lives near the incident what they think of a little girl getting shot. What do they expect people to say? "Hey, no big deal. People get shot here all the time. What really makes me mad is the Twins letting Johan Santana get away."

Actually, there was one detail of the Strib story that's kind of funny. The assailant's gun went off because his pants were so loose that the gun slipped down his pants leg and discharged when it hit the floor. How much funnier would the headline have been if the gun had hit with the muzzle pointed straight up?

"Man, 20 or so, grazed by bullet, leaving future generations hurt, too."

advertisement
If I were king of the fore-e-e-est

If I were king of the fore-e-e-est

Submitted by Tom Bartel on Monday, February 4, 2008

I hope you all noticed the bold initiative of the Star Tribune, as expressed on their editorial page on Sunday. Yup, they put their heads together, snorted and wheezed with the Herculean effort, pressed hard on their temples to concentrate the intellect, and made their endorsement regarding tomorrow's "Super Tuesday" nationwide primaries and caucuses.

And you thought they were too timid to actually make an endorsement without doing a focus group first of what they could get away with without offending their ever shrinking base of readers and advertisers.

Well, the joke's on you. The Strib editorial board ain't afraid of nobody or no thing. Not nobody. Not nohow.

Continued advertisement

And just to prove that, they threw caution to the wind, damned the torpedoes, hurled themselves once more into the breach and endorsed...voting.

As they put it, "Super Tuesday, Too important to miss." If that weren't endorsement enough, they even said,"It could be a transformative moment in American politics."

That's some bold talkin' there.

So whatever you do, don't miss Super Tuesday. It's too important AND it could be transformative.

And speaking of "Super", how 'bout them Giants? They made the top of the Strib's front page today, right above the coverage of the candidates.

Subscribe to the The Read Menace Blog RSS Feed